Speca › Topics › GCSE Psychology

Development

AQA GCSE Psychology · Paper 1

Development covers how the brain grows, Piaget's four stages, two studies that challenge Piaget, and ideas about learning from Dweck and Willingham. This page shows how to build each kind of answer one step at a time.

Using the Speca Psychology Workbook?This is topic 3. Work through an example below, then go back to the questions in the book. The answers are at the back of the book.

Stuck? Worked examples, step by step

How to answer each kind of question in this topic. Cover the model answer, try it yourself, then check each step.

Also on this page: how longer answers are marked, with sample answers at each level · sentence starters

Explain · 2 marks

Explaining a key word: equilibrium

Explain what is meant by equilibrium in Piaget's theory. [2 marks]

The question names Piaget's theory, so the answer needs the meaning (1) and what it has to do with development (1). Begin with the plain meaning. If the word is hard, think of what 'balance' feels like.

Equilibrium is a state of balance, when what a child already knows fits what they experience. (1)

Now say what happens when the balance goes. That is the part that links it to development. Ask: what does a child do when something new does not fit?

When a new experience does not fit, the balance is upset, and the child changes their schema (accommodation) to restore it. Restoring balance is what drives development. (1)

Why it scores: the first sentence defines the word and the second links it to development. A common slip is to write that equilibrium is when a child is 'happy' or 'settled'. It is about what the child knows fitting what they experience.

Explain · 3 marks

Explaining a difference between two stages

Explain one way a child in the concrete operational stage thinks differently from a child in the pre-operational stage. [3 marks]

Pick one clear difference and give both sides. A good one is conservation. Aim for: the younger child (1), the older child (1), and a short explanation or example (1). Piaget's ages are approximate, so say 'roughly' when you give them.

A child in the pre-operational stage (roughly 2 to 7) cannot conserve, whereas a child in the concrete operational stage (roughly 7 to 11) can. (1)

Now explain what conservation means, in case the examiner wants to see you know. Use your own words and give a quick example.

Conservation means knowing that a quantity, such as the number of counters, stays the same when its appearance changes, for example when one row is spread out. (1)

Last, say what each child would do or say. This makes the difference clear and concrete.

So a younger child often says the longer row now has more, whereas an older child knows the number has not changed. (1)

Why it scores: it names both stages, uses the key term correctly and ends with what a child would actually do. Do not say a child 'can' or 'cannot' do something at an exact age. These are rough ages.

Apply · 4 marks

Using Dweck's theory on a pupil

Owen fails a spelling test and says, 'I'm just bad at spelling, there's no point trying.' His teacher wants to help. Use Dweck's theory to identify Owen's mindset and explain what the teacher should do. [4 marks]

Step 1, spot the idea. Owen is saying his ability is set and effort is pointless. The theory with two mindsets is Dweck's. Step 2, name it, using the correct key term and what it means.

Owen has a fixed mindset, which means believing that ability is set and cannot change much. (1)

Step 3, link it to Owen. Quote or use his words, so it is clear you have used the story.

He says he is 'just bad' at spelling and there is 'no point trying', which shows he sees effort as pointless and is giving up. (1)

Step 4, explain what the teacher should do. Be specific: what would she say? Dweck's idea is a growth mindset, which is a belief that ability can grow with effort and good strategies.

The teacher should encourage a growth mindset, the belief that ability can grow through effort and good strategies. For example, she could say, 'You can get better at spelling if we try a new way to learn these words.' (1)

Add one more fact about praise, because Dweck's theory is about praise too.

When Owen improves, she should praise his effort and strategies, not say he is clever, because praising fixed ability may encourage a fixed mindset. (1)

Why it scores: the right term is named and explained, the story is used, and the advice is specific. Growth mindset is not just 'trying hard'. It is a belief about whether ability can change, so say that.

Describe a study · 4 marks

Describing Hughes' policeman doll study

Describe the aim, results and conclusion of Hughes' policeman doll study. [4 marks]

Write the parts the question names, in order. Four marks is about four facts, so give the results two. Start with the aim: what was Hughes trying to find out about young children?

The aim was to test whether young children can take another person's point of view when the task makes sense to them. (1)

Now the results. Give the main number first, with who the children were. Then add the extra detail about harder versions of the task.

About 90% of the children, who were roughly 3 and a half to 5, hid the boy doll where neither policeman could see him. (1)

Most still succeeded when the layout was made more complicated, though the youngest children found this harder. (1)

Last, the conclusion. Link it to Piaget, because the study was written to test one of his ideas.

The conclusion was that children are less egocentric than Piaget suggested, when the task is a hiding game they understand. (1)

Why it scores: aim, two results and the conclusion are each a separate fact. Write 'about 90%' not 'all of them'. The study challenges Piaget's ages. It does not say he was wrong that the abilities develop.

Evaluate · 3 marks

One strength of Willingham's criticism, built in four steps

Explain one strength of Willingham's criticism of learning styles. [3 marks]

Use the four-part chain: Point (the strength), Evidence (what supports it), Explain (why it matters), Link back (what it means for the theory or for teachers). Start with the point. Remember that Willingham is criticising learning styles, so the strength is about why his criticism is a good one.

One strength is that reviews of the evidence support Willingham. They found little evidence that matching teaching to a pupil's preferred style improves learning. (1)

Now explain why that matters. Ask: if a teacher sorts pupils into 'visualisers' and 'verbalisers', what is the cost?

A teacher who sorts pupils into visualisers and verbalisers would spend time on something that has not been shown to help, when that time could go on choosing the format that suits the content, for example a map for geography. (1)

Finally, link back to what Willingham actually says teachers should do.

So his criticism gives teachers a good reason to stop sorting pupils by style and to choose the format that suits the content and help pupils think about meaning. (1)

Why it scores: the strength is named and backed with evidence, the explanation is about teaching, and the last sentence links to Willingham's advice. If you want a counterpoint for a longer answer, you could add that varied presentation may help some learners, but liking one format is not the same as format making no difference.

Plan a 6-mark answer

Planning an answer that uses both studies

Explain how McGarrigle and Donaldson's study and Hughes' study challenge Piaget's theory. [6 marks]

Six marks, two studies, so plan about 2 marks for each study and 2 for the idea that links them. For each study use: what they did (1), what they found (1), what it challenges (1). Plan before you write.

Your plan: Paragraph 1, Piaget's claims: young children cannot conserve or take another's view, at roughly these ages. Paragraph 2, McGarrigle and Donaldson: naughty teddy, about 62% against about 16%, so children conserve earlier. Paragraph 3, Hughes: policeman doll, about 90% succeeded, so less egocentric. Final sentence: the studies challenge the ages, but the abilities still develop.

Now write paragraph 2 as a model. Say what the researchers tested, what they found with the numbers, and then what that does to Piaget's claim.

McGarrigle and Donaldson tested whether children aged roughly 4 to 6 could conserve number when the change to the counters looked accidental. When a naughty teddy appeared to mess up one row by accident, about 62% of children said the rows were still equal, compared with about 16% when an adult spread them out on purpose. This challenges Piaget because it shows children can conserve earlier than he claimed. His questions may have led children to think the change was meant to matter. (3)

Paragraph 3 is the same pattern with Hughes' doll task, so you write it yourself. Finish with the linking sentence that both studies suggest Piaget underestimated young children, but accept that the abilities do develop.

Why it scores: the answer is about what the studies show for Piaget, not just a story of what happened in each. Each paragraph has a result and says what it does to Piaget's claim.

Research methods · 7 marks

Hypothesis, means and ethics with young children

Mia wants to test whether the type of praise changes how long children keep trying at a hard puzzle. Ten children aged 7 are split into two groups of five. Group A are praised for effort ('you worked hard'). Group B are praised for being clever ('you're so clever'). Each child then gets a hard puzzle and is timed on how many minutes they keep trying. Minutes tried, group A: 9, 12, 7, 12, 10. Minutes tried, group B: 6, 8, 5, 9, 7. (a) Write an alternative hypothesis. [2 marks] (b) Calculate the mean for each group. [3 marks] (c) Explain one ethical issue and how Mia should deal with it. [2 marks]

Part (a). An alternative hypothesis predicts a difference and says which way. Make the variables measurable: say how each is measured. The IV is the type of praise. The DV is minutes spent trying. Use Dweck's idea to decide the direction.

Children who are praised for effort will keep trying at a hard puzzle for more minutes than children who are praised for being clever. (2)

Part (b). The mean is: add up all the scores, then divide by how many scores there are. Do group A first. Show each step on its own line.

Group A: 9 + 12 + 7 + 12 + 10 = 50, and 50 ÷ 5 = 10 minutes (1 + 1)

Now group B, with the same two steps.

Group B: 6 + 8 + 5 + 9 + 7 = 35, and 35 ÷ 5 = 7 minutes (1)

Group A's mean is 3 minutes higher (10 - 7 = 3). That fits the hypothesis, but with only five children in each group, you should say it is not certain.

Part (c). Name the issue, then say how to deal with it. The children are 7, so the main issue is informed consent.

Informed consent: the children are too young to understand fully what the study involves, so Mia must explain the study and get agreement from their parents or carers first. (1) She should also tell the children they can stop at any time. (1)

Why it scores: the hypothesis names both variables and says which way, each mean shows its steps and unit, and the ethics answer names the issue and the action. Notice that Mia used different children in each group, because a child praised one way could not then be praised the other way without the first praise having an effect.

Longer answers: structure and levels

Longer questions, worth 4, 6 or 9 marks, are usually marked in levels: the whole answer is read, the level that fits best is chosen, then a mark inside it. These descriptions are Speca's own guide, the same as the one printed in the workbook; the real exam uses the exam board's mark schemes.

How to structure them

4 marksTwo points, each explained, or one point described and then explained in detail. If the question has a story in it, use the person's name in every point.
6 marksThree short paragraphs. To evaluate, use point, evidence, explain, link back in each one, and cover a strength and a weakness. To apply, name the idea, link it to the person in the story, then explain it. Finish with one sentence of judgement if the question asks you to evaluate.
9 marksDescribe first: the theory or study, accurately, in a paragraph. If the question only says evaluate, keep this short. Then two or three evaluation points, each fully explained and using a study as evidence. Cover strengths and weaknesses. End with a judgement that answers the question. Do not spend all your time describing: the higher levels need evaluation as well.
TimingThe papers give 1 hour 45 minutes for 100 marks, so about a minute a mark: roughly 9 or 10 minutes for a 9-mark answer, including a minute to plan.

The levels for a 4-mark answer

LevelWhat it looks like
3 to 4 marksClear, accurate and detailed. Each point is explained, and where there is a scenario the answer uses it. Psychological terms are used correctly.
1 to 2 marksSome relevant knowledge, but brief, muddled, or not applied to the question.
0 marksNothing relevant.

The levels for a 6-mark answer

LevelWhat it looks like
5 to 6 marksSeveral relevant points, each explained clearly and accurately. If the question asks for evaluation, it says why each point matters. If there is a scenario, every point is applied to it. Well organised, with accurate terms.
3 to 4 marksRelevant points with some explanation, but some are thin, one-sided or only partly applied.
1 to 2 marksPoints are listed or described but not explained, or the answer is mostly off the question.
0 marksNothing relevant.

The levels for a 9-mark answer

LevelWhat it looks like
7 to 9 marksAccurate, detailed description and well-developed evaluation, using a study as evidence. Strengths and weaknesses are both covered, and the answer reaches a judgement. Clearly organised, with accurate terms.
4 to 6 marksMostly accurate description with some evaluation, which may be one-sided or not fully explained. A study may be mentioned but not used as evidence.
1 to 3 marksLimited description, with little or no evaluation, or with errors.
0 marksNothing relevant.

One question, three answers

Describe and evaluate the use of Piaget's theory in the classroom. Refer to Hughes' study in your answer. [9 marks]

Read each answer, then the note on why it sits in that level. Try writing your own first, then compare.

Level 1: about 2 marks out of 9

Piaget said children learn by doing things. A teacher should let the children discover things for themselves. This is called discovery learning. Teachers should also not teach things too early. Hughes did a study with a policeman doll and found that most children could hide the doll. This shows Piaget was right that children are egocentric and cannot see things from other people's view. Piaget's ideas are good for schools because children learn more by doing.

Why this level: Discovery learning is named and explained, but the other classroom ideas (readiness, the teacher as a guide, challenge) are only hinted at. The answer also makes a mistake: Hughes' study challenges Piaget, because most young children could take the policemen's point of view. The evaluation is a single sentence with no reason or evidence.

Level 2: about 5 marks out of 9

Piaget's theory has several ideas for the classroom. The first is readiness: teachers should not teach an idea before a child is cognitively ready for it. The second is discovery learning, where children learn best by doing, exploring and handling real things. The teacher is a guide who sets up activities rather than someone who just tells. Teachers can also set tasks that do not quite fit what pupils know. This upsets the balance, or equilibrium, so pupils have to accommodate, which means changing their schemas.

A strength of Piaget's ideas is that he was hugely influential. His theory led to child-centred, active learning in schools, so pupils get to do and explore things themselves. A weakness is that he may have underestimated young children. Hughes found that children could hide a doll from two policemen, so they are less egocentric than Piaget said. This means readiness might be a problem. Overall Piaget's ideas are useful but they are not perfect.

Why this level: The description covers the main classroom ideas accurately, and there is a strength and a weakness. But the weakness is underdeveloped: Hughes' study is mentioned without its results or limits, and 'readiness might be a problem' is not explained. The ending is a short opinion rather than a judgement.

Level 3: about 8 marks out of 9

Piaget's theory has several uses in the classroom. Readiness means a teacher should not teach an idea before a child is at the stage of development where they can understand it. Discovery learning means children learn best by doing, exploring and handling real things, and the teacher acts as a guide who sets up activities instead of just telling. Teachers can also set challenges that do not quite fit what pupils already know. This upsets the balance (equilibrium) and pushes pupils to accommodate, which means changing their schemas, and restoring the balance is what drives development.

A strength is that Piaget was hugely influential. His ideas led to child-centred, active learning. Handling real things also fits his claim that children in the concrete operational stage are logical about real objects.

However, there are weaknesses. Hughes tested whether young children can take another person's point of view when the task makes sense to them. About 90% of the children, aged roughly 3 and a half to 5, hid a boy doll where neither policeman could see him. This challenges Piaget, who said children at this age are egocentric. It matters in the classroom: if teachers wait for readiness, they might wait too long before teaching ideas that children could already manage. Piaget's stages may also not be as neat as he thought, which makes readiness hard to judge. There is a counterpoint, because Hughes used a small sample of young children and an artificial model, so the study may not show how they think in everyday life. It also suggests Piaget's ages were too late, not that the abilities do not develop.

Overall, I think Piaget's ideas are worth using, especially active learning and challenge, because they led to useful changes in schools. But the evidence from Hughes suggests teachers should treat his ages and readiness as rough guides, and give young children tasks that make sense to them.

Why this level: The description is accurate and detailed. Hughes' study is used as real evidence: the answer gives the result and links it to the classroom idea of readiness, then notes the study's limits. Strengths and weaknesses are both developed, and the answer ends with a judgement that gives reasons.

How to move up a level

Sentence starters

Stuck on how to begin? Pick a starter and finish the sentence in your own words. The first set is for this topic; the second works for any topic.

For this topic

For any topic

What this topic covers

Where students lose marks

Key terms

Brain stem
The part of the brain that controls automatic functions such as breathing and heart rate.
Thalamus
The part of the brain that passes incoming sensory information to the right areas.
Cerebellum
The part of the brain that coordinates movement, balance and posture.
Cortex
The outer part of the brain used for thinking, language and planning.
Nature
What we are born with, such as genes.
Nurture
What happens to us, such as experiences, stimulation and nutrition.
Schema
A mental framework of what we know about something.
Assimilation
Fitting new information into a schema we already have.
Accommodation
Changing a schema, or making a new one, because new information does not fit.
Equilibrium
Balance, when what we know fits what we experience.
Object permanence
Knowing an object still exists when you cannot see it.
Egocentrism
Being unable to see things from another person's point of view.
Conservation
Knowing a quantity stays the same when its appearance changes.
Decentring
Focusing on more than one feature of a problem at once.
Readiness
Being at the stage of development where a child can understand an idea.
Fixed mindset
Believing ability is set and cannot change much.
Growth mindset
Believing ability can grow through effort and good strategies.
Self-efficacy
Belief in your own ability to succeed at a particular task.
Learning styles
The idea that people learn best in one preferred way, such as words or pictures.

More GCSE Psychology topics