Speca › Topics › GCSE Psychology

Psychological Problems

AQA GCSE Psychology · Paper 2

This topic covers mental health, depression and addiction: what they are, how doctors recognise them, how they are explained and how they are treated. This page shows how to answer each kind of question, one step at a time. If anything here worries you, talk to a trusted adult, your school or your GP.

Using the Speca Psychology Workbook?This is topic 8. Work through an example below, then go back to the questions in the book. The answers are at the back of the book.

Stuck? Worked examples, step by step

How to answer each kind of question in this topic. Cover the model answer, try it yourself, then check each step.

Also on this page: how longer answers are marked, with sample answers at each level · sentence starters

Define · 2 marks

Outline a difference

Outline the difference between unipolar and bipolar depression. [2 marks]

A 'difference' question needs both sides, joined by a word such as 'whereas' or 'but'. Writing about only one side cannot earn both marks. First, the unipolar side.

Unipolar depression is long-lasting low mood and related symptoms.

Now the bipolar side. The key feature is that it goes both ways: depression and then unusually high mood, called mania.

Bipolar depression is periods of depression that alternate with periods of unusually high mood, called mania.

Join them into one clear sentence.

Unipolar depression is long-lasting low mood, whereas bipolar depression has periods of depression that alternate with periods of unusually high mood, called mania.

Why it scores: it gives both sides and uses a link word, so the difference is clear. Do not describe bipolar depression as 'mood swings'. It is a specific pattern of depression alternating with mania.

Explain · 3 marks

Explain how a treatment works

Explain how antidepressants aim to help someone with depression. [3 marks]

Three marks means three points. Think: what is the aim, what do they change, and how. Start with the aim.

Antidepressants are medicines that aim to improve mood.

Now say what they change in the brain. The word to use is neurotransmitter.

They work by increasing the amount of neurotransmitter available in the brain, for example serotonin.

Add the 'how'. Reuptake is when a neurotransmitter is taken back up into the neuron that released it.

One way they do this is by reducing reuptake, so less serotonin is taken back up and more is left available.

Why it scores: it gives the aim, the change in the brain and the way it happens. It also fits the biological explanation, which links depression to low levels of serotonin. Say 'aim to help', not 'cure', because the medicines do not work for everyone.

Apply · 4 marks

Use an idea on a new situation

Fiona is an adult who has had serious problems with alcohol. She joins a weekly 12-step group where members support each other and work through structured steps. Use your knowledge of self-management programmes to explain how the group could help Fiona, and give one limitation. [4 marks]

Step 1, spot the idea. 'Members support each other' and 'structured steps' are the signs of a self-management programme. Self-help groups and 12-step programmes are both examples.

Fiona's 12-step group is a self-management programme, where people support each other and work through structured steps towards recovery.

Step 2, link a benefit to Fiona. Use details from the story, not general facts.

Fiona can get ongoing support from the other members, and the structured steps give her a clear path to follow towards recovery.

Step 3, add a second benefit if you can. Two more benefits from your notes are that it is low cost and more holistic.

The group is also low cost, and it is more holistic than a treatment such as aversion therapy because it looks at the whole person.

Step 4, give one limitation. The question asked for one, so one clear limitation is enough.

However, it relies on Fiona's motivation to keep going, and many people drop out.

Why it scores: it names the programme, links two benefits to Fiona, and gives a limitation. A fair examiner would credit each. If you only give benefits, you leave out the limitation the question asked for.

Study · 4 marks

Describe a named study

Describe Wiles' study of cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT). Include the sample, how the adults were put into groups, and the main result. [4 marks]

The question gives you the plan: sample, groups, result. Start with the sample. The adults were chosen because antidepressants had not helped enough.

Wiles' study was a large trial in UK GP practices with 469 adults whose depression had not improved enough with antidepressants.

Now the groups. The key word is 'randomly', so use it.

The adults were allocated at random to either usual care, which included antidepressants, or usual care plus a course of CBT.

Say how it was measured. This is a short step but it is a separate point.

A depression questionnaire measured symptoms at the start and at follow-up points.

Now the result. Use the figures and name both groups.

After six months, 46% of the CBT group had at least halved their depression score, compared with 22% of the usual-care group.

Why it scores: it has the sample, the random groups, the measure and the result with both figures. A fair examiner would credit around four of these. If asked for the conclusion, say that CBT added to medication worked better than medication alone for these adults.

Evaluate · 3 marks

Build one evaluation point

Explain one strength of CBT as a treatment for depression. [3 marks]

Use four parts: Point, Evidence, Explain, Link. Start with the Point.

One strength of CBT is that research supports it, including for people who have not been helped enough by medication.

Evidence: use the figures from Wiles' study. Say what was compared.

In Wiles' study, after six months 46% of adults who had CBT in addition to usual care had at least halved their depression score, compared with 22% who had usual care alone.

Explain: say what the figures show.

This shows that adding CBT did better than medication alone for these adults, so CBT can help when antidepressants have not been enough.

Link: finish by tying back to the question.

So CBT is a useful treatment for depression.

Why it scores: it makes a point, backs it with figures from a named study, and explains what the figures mean. Writing only 'it is good because it works' would have no evidence behind it.

Plan a 6-mark answer

Plan, then write the hardest paragraph

Evaluate the biological explanation of depression. [6 marks]

Step 1, decode. 'Evaluate' means weigh it up: what is good about it, what is weak about it, and an overall view. A description alone will not earn the top marks.

Step 2, plan. Paragraph 1: say what the explanation is (depression is linked to an imbalance of neurotransmitters, such as low serotonin). Paragraph 2: a strength (medicines that change serotonin levels help many people). Paragraph 3: weaknesses (low serotonin may be a result, medicines do not work for everyone, and it is reductionist). Finish with a one-line overall view.

Step 3, write the weaknesses paragraph first, because it is where the extra marks are. Use 'however' to show you are moving from strengths to weaknesses.

However, the biological explanation has weaknesses. Low serotonin may be a result of depression and not the cause, so the link does not prove that it causes depression. Also, medicines that change serotonin levels do not work for everyone, which suggests serotonin cannot be the whole explanation.

Finally, it is reductionist, because it explains depression only at the level of brain chemistry and leaves out thoughts and life events.

Step 4, finish with a short overall view.

Overall, low serotonin is a linked explanation, not a proven sole cause, so a full explanation also needs to include psychological factors.

Why it scores: it gives reasons that go beyond 'it is reductionist', it says what each weakness means, and it ends with a judgement. Do not call reductionist 'bad'. It means explaining at one level, which has strengths too.

Research methods · 6 marks

Percentages and what they do not prove

Rosa surveys 40 adults. 20 say most of their friends smoke, and 12 of them smoke. 20 say most of their friends do not smoke, and 4 of them smoke. The figures are invented. (a) Calculate the percentage who smoke in each group. [2 marks] (b) Say what the results suggest about peer influence. [2 marks] (c) Explain why the results do not show that friends cause smoking. [2 marks]

Part (a). Use part ÷ whole × 100. The 'whole' is 20 people in each group. Show the sum.

Friends mostly smoke: 12 ÷ 20 × 100 = 60%.

Friends mostly do not smoke: 4 ÷ 20 × 100 = 20%.

Part (b). Compare the two figures, then link them to the explanation.

Smoking was three times as common when most friends smoked (60%) as when they did not (20%). This suggests peer influence may play a part in smoking.

Part (c). This is a survey, not an experiment, so look for other explanations.

The survey only shows a link. People who already smoke may choose friends who smoke, and other factors, such as family or stress, could explain both.

Why it scores: the working is shown, the comparison is made, the result is linked to peer influence, and the answer says what the data cannot prove. A link between two things is not proof that one causes the other.

Longer answers: structure and levels

Longer questions, worth 4, 6 or 9 marks, are usually marked in levels: the whole answer is read, the level that fits best is chosen, then a mark inside it. These descriptions are Speca's own guide, the same as the one printed in the workbook; the real exam uses the exam board's mark schemes.

How to structure them

4 marksTwo points, each explained, or one point described and then explained in detail. If the question has a story in it, use the person's name in every point.
6 marksThree short paragraphs. To evaluate, use point, evidence, explain, link back in each one, and cover a strength and a weakness. To apply, name the idea, link it to the person in the story, then explain it. Finish with one sentence of judgement if the question asks you to evaluate.
9 marksDescribe first: the theory or study, accurately, in a paragraph. If the question only says evaluate, keep this short. Then two or three evaluation points, each fully explained and using a study as evidence. Cover strengths and weaknesses. End with a judgement that answers the question. Do not spend all your time describing: the higher levels need evaluation as well.
TimingThe papers give 1 hour 45 minutes for 100 marks, so about a minute a mark: roughly 9 or 10 minutes for a 9-mark answer, including a minute to plan.

The levels for a 4-mark answer

LevelWhat it looks like
3 to 4 marksClear, accurate and detailed. Each point is explained, and where there is a scenario the answer uses it. Psychological terms are used correctly.
1 to 2 marksSome relevant knowledge, but brief, muddled, or not applied to the question.
0 marksNothing relevant.

The levels for a 6-mark answer

LevelWhat it looks like
5 to 6 marksSeveral relevant points, each explained clearly and accurately. If the question asks for evaluation, it says why each point matters. If there is a scenario, every point is applied to it. Well organised, with accurate terms.
3 to 4 marksRelevant points with some explanation, but some are thin, one-sided or only partly applied.
1 to 2 marksPoints are listed or described but not explained, or the answer is mostly off the question.
0 marksNothing relevant.

The levels for a 9-mark answer

LevelWhat it looks like
7 to 9 marksAccurate, detailed description and well-developed evaluation, using a study as evidence. Strengths and weaknesses are both covered, and the answer reaches a judgement. Clearly organised, with accurate terms.
4 to 6 marksMostly accurate description with some evaluation, which may be one-sided or not fully explained. A study may be mentioned but not used as evidence.
1 to 3 marksLimited description, with little or no evaluation, or with errors.
0 marksNothing relevant.

One question, three answers

Describe and evaluate CBT as a treatment for depression. Refer to Wiles' study in your answer. [9 marks]

Read each answer, then the note on why it sits in that level. Try writing your own first, then compare.

Level 1: about 2 marks out of 9

CBT is when you talk about your feelings to a therapist and it makes you feel better. It is just talking. Wiles did a study in UK GP practices with 469 adults and found that CBT worked. A good thing about it is that it is better than medicine. It is the best treatment for depression.

Why this level: CBT is described as just talking about feelings, which is a common mistake: it is a talking therapy that spots negative thoughts, challenges them and changes unhelpful behaviour. The claims that it is better than medicine and the best treatment go further than Wiles found, which was that CBT added to medication did better than medication alone. There is no detail about the study and no weakness.

Level 2: about 5 marks out of 9

CBT stands for cognitive behaviour therapy. It is a talking therapy where a person works with a therapist to spot negative thoughts, challenge them and replace them with more balanced ones, and to change unhelpful behaviour. Wiles carried out a large trial in UK GP practices with 469 adults whose depression had not improved enough with antidepressants. They were allocated at random to either usual care, including antidepressants, or usual care plus a course of CBT. After six months, 46% of the CBT group had at least halved their depression score, compared with 22% of the usual-care group. This shows that CBT added to medication worked better than medication alone. CBT has strengths. It tackles thinking patterns, which antidepressants do not, and it may reduce relapse. It is also supported by Wiles' study, which had a large sample, random allocation and real patients in real GP practices. This makes the findings more trustworthy. CBT also looks at the whole person, so it is more holistic.

Why this level: CBT and Wiles' study are described accurately, with the figures. The evaluation only gives strengths, so it is one-sided, and the study is used to describe more than to weigh the treatment. There are no weaknesses and no overall judgement.

Level 3: about 8 marks out of 9

CBT stands for cognitive behaviour therapy. It is a talking therapy in which a person works with a therapist to spot negative thoughts, challenge them and replace them with more balanced ones, and to change unhelpful behaviour. It links to the psychological explanation of depression, which says depression is linked to negative schemas, which are fixed negative ways of thinking about yourself, the world and the future. Wiles' study tested whether adding CBT helps adults whose depression had not improved enough with antidepressants. It was a large trial in UK GP practices with 469 adults, who were allocated at random to either usual care, including antidepressants, or usual care plus a course of CBT. After six months, 46% of the CBT group had at least halved their depression score, compared with 22% of the usual-care group. The conclusion was that CBT added to medication works better than medication alone for people whose depression has not responded to antidepressants. This is a strength of CBT. The study had a large sample, random allocation and real patients, so the evidence is fairly strong. CBT also tackles thinking patterns and may reduce relapse, and it is more holistic than antidepressants, which change brain chemistry and can have side effects.

However, there are limits. The study used self-report questionnaires, the patients knew which treatment they were having, and not everyone finished the treatment. CBT also needs time, motivation and access to a therapist, so it may not suit everyone.

Overall, the evidence suggests CBT is a useful treatment, especially when it is added to medication that has not been enough on its own, but it is not the right choice for everyone, so the best treatment depends on the person.

Why this level: The description is accurate and detailed, linking CBT to the psychological explanation and giving Wiles' method, figures and conclusion. Strengths and weaknesses are both covered and explained, for the treatment and for the study. The answer ends with a balanced judgement that follows from the evidence.

How to move up a level

Sentence starters

Stuck on how to begin? Pick a starter and finish the sentence in your own words. The first set is for this topic; the second works for any topic.

For this topic

For any topic

What this topic covers

Where students lose marks

Key terms

Mental health
How well we are able to cope with life, relationships and setbacks.
Incidence
How common something is, or how often it is recorded.
Stigma
Shame or unfair judgement linked to something, which can stop people asking for help.
Unipolar depression
Long-lasting low mood and related symptoms.
Bipolar depression
Periods of depression that alternate with periods of unusually high mood, called mania.
Symptom
A sign that a person has a problem, such as poor sleep or low energy.
Serotonin
A neurotransmitter linked to mood.
Negative schema
A fixed, negative way of thinking about yourself, the world and the future.
Attribution
The reason a person gives for why something happened.
Antidepressant
A medicine that aims to improve mood by changing the levels of neurotransmitters.
CBT
Cognitive behaviour therapy: a talking therapy that challenges unhelpful thoughts and behaviour.
Reductionist
Explaining or treating a problem at one simple level, such as brain chemistry.
Holistic
Looking at the whole person, including thoughts, relationships and circumstances.
Dependence
A strong need for a substance, with loss of control over using it.
Substance misuse
Harmful use of a substance, which does not always involve dependence.
Genetic vulnerability
Inherited genes that make some people more likely to develop a problem.
Peer influence
Friends and social groups shaping our attitudes and behaviour.
Aversion therapy
Linking a substance with an unpleasant experience so that a person comes to avoid it.
Self-management programme
Support where people help themselves and each other, such as a 12-step group.
Concordance
When both twins in a pair share the same problem.

More GCSE Psychology topics