Speca › Topics › GCSE Psychology
Language, Thought and Communication
AQA GCSE Psychology · Paper 2
This topic is about how language and thinking are linked, how animals pass on messages, and how people communicate without words. This page shows how to answer each kind of question, one step at a time.
Stuck? Worked examples, step by step
How to answer each kind of question in this topic. Cover the model answer, try it yourself, then check each step.
Also on this page: how longer answers are marked, with sample answers at each level · sentence starters
- Explain what a term means
- Explain why something counts
- Use an idea on a new situation
- Describe a named study
- Build one evaluation point
- Plan, then write one paragraph
- Means and making counts fair
Define · 2 marks
Explain what a term means
Explain what is meant by linguistic relativity. [2 marks]
Two similar terms get mixed up here. Linguistic determinism is the strong view: language decides what we are able to think. Linguistic relativity is the weaker view: language influences how we think. Here we need the weaker one.
Linguistic relativity is the weaker version of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis. It says that the language we speak influences how we think.
For the second mark, say what kind of thing language might influence.
For example, the language we speak may influence what we notice and remember.
Why it scores: the first sentence gives the meaning and places it as the weaker version, and the second adds what is influenced. Using the word 'influences' matters. If you write 'decides' or 'limits', you have described the strong version by mistake.
Explain · 2 marks
Explain why something counts
Explain why tone of voice is an example of non-verbal communication. [2 marks]
When a question asks 'why does this count', first show you know the two kinds. Verbal uses words. Non-verbal does not.
Verbal communication passes on a message with words, spoken or written, while non-verbal communication passes on a message without words.
Now apply it. The key point is how something is said, not what is said.
Tone of voice is non-verbal because it is how something is said, not the words themselves.
A short example makes the answer clearer. Use the same words said two ways.
For example, 'fine' said in a cheerful voice and 'fine' said in a flat voice send different messages, even though the words are the same.
Why it scores: it separates the two kinds of communication, and then shows why tone of voice sits on the non-verbal side. Many pupils lose the mark by writing that tone of voice is verbal because it comes from the mouth.
Apply · 3 marks
Use an idea on a new situation
Every morning a robin sits on top of a garden fence and sings loudly. When another robin lands in the garden, the first robin sings louder and chases it away. Identify the function of the robin's singing and explain your answer. [3 marks]
Step 1, spot the idea. Animal signals have a small number of jobs. Learn the four: survival (alarm calls), reproduction (courtship displays), territory (songs and marking) and food (signalling where it is).
Step 2, test each job against the story. Is the robin warning of danger? No. Is it courting a mate? No. Is it showing where food is? No. It is singing from a fixed spot and chasing off a newcomer. That points to territory.
The function of the robin's singing is territory.
Step 3, link to the story. Use the details.
The robin sings from the fence and chases the other robin away when it lands in the garden.
Step 4, explain how the signal does that job.
The song tells other robins that this garden is already taken, so the singing helps the robin to keep its territory.
Why it scores: it names one function clearly, uses details from the story, and explains how the song does the job. Only name one function. Listing two can lose the mark if one is wrong.
Study · 4 marks
Describe a named study
Describe Yuki's study of emoticons. Include who took part, what they did and what the researchers found. [4 marks]
The question gives you your plan: who, what they did, what was found. Start with who took part, and include both groups.
Yuki's study used university students from two cultures: 95 from Japan and 118 from the USA.
Next, what they had to do. Be specific about the rating.
They rated how happy or sad emoticons looked on a 9-point scale. The eyes and the mouth of each emoticon were changed separately, so the researchers could tell which part people used.
Now the results. Name each group and say which part of the face it relied on.
Japanese participants gave more weight to the eyes, while American participants gave more weight to the mouth. A second study using photographs of real faces found the same pattern.
Why it scores: it has the sample, the task, the key control (changing eyes and mouth separately) and both results. A fair examiner would credit about four of these points. If you are asked what the results mean, add that how we read faces seems to be shaped by culture, so it is partly learned.
Evaluate · 3 marks
Build one evaluation point
Explain one strength of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis. [3 marks]
Use four parts: Point, Evidence, Explain, Link. Start with the Point. It should be a strength of the idea, in one sentence.
One strength of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis is that research on colour and memory shows that language can affect perception and recall.
Evidence: use the Zuni colour example. Say exactly what was found.
Early research found that Zuni speakers, whose language has one word that covers both yellow and orange, were more likely to mix up those two colours and remembered them less well than English speakers, who have a separate word for each.
Explain: say why this evidence supports the idea.
This is measurable evidence that having a word for something can change how well people tell things apart and remember them.
Link: say which version it supports. Be careful here.
This supports the weaker version, linguistic relativity, that language influences thought. It does not show that language decides what we can think.
Why it scores: it makes a point, backs it with a named example, explains it, and links to the right version. The link matters because the strong version is not supported by the evidence.
Plan a 6-mark answer
Plan, then write one paragraph
Explain how animal communication is different from human language. Refer to von Frisch's study in your answer. [6 marks]
Step 1, decode. 'Different from' means you need both sides in each paragraph: animals on one side, humans on the other. Six marks means about three paragraphs.
Step 2, plan. Paragraph 1: animal communication has a few jobs and is tied to its function (use von Frisch). Paragraph 2: displacement, which humans have and animals mostly do not. Paragraph 3: creativity, making endless new messages from a limited set of words.
Step 3, add a final line that is fair to animals. Animals do communicate. Their signals are limited and tied to a job.
Step 4, write paragraph 1. Start by saying what animal signals do, then bring in the study, then contrast with humans.
Animal communication has a small number of jobs, such as survival, reproduction, territory and food, and each signal is tied to one of them. Von Frisch's study shows this. Returning honeybees performed a round dance for food close to the hive and a waggle dance for food further away, and the waggle dance showed the direction and distance.
However, the dances only carry information about finding food, so the bees' system is clever but limited. Human language is different because it can be used for almost anything we can think of.
Why it scores: it uses the study as evidence, and it states the difference instead of just describing animals. Never write that animals cannot communicate. They can. The point is that their signals are limited and tied to a function.
Research methods · 5 marks
Means and making counts fair
Grace and Joel want to find out whether friends copy each other's posture more than strangers do. They watch 5 pairs of friends and 5 pairs of strangers sitting together for five minutes each. They count each time one person copies the other's posture. Friends: 6, 4, 7, 5, 8. Strangers: 1, 3, 0, 2, 4. (a) Calculate the mean number of copies for each group. [2 marks] (b) Say what the results suggest. [2 marks] (c) Suggest one way to make sure Grace and Joel count in the same way. [1 mark]
Part (a). The mean is the total divided by how many numbers there are. Add up first. Show the sum.
Friends: 6 + 4 + 7 + 5 + 8 = 30, and 30 ÷ 5 = 6.
Strangers: 1 + 3 + 0 + 2 + 4 = 10, and 10 ÷ 5 = 2.
Part (b). Compare the two means, then link to the idea. Copying another person's posture is called postural echo, and it signals rapport.
Friends copied each other's posture a mean of 6 times, compared with 2 times for strangers. This suggests that postural echo is more common between people who have rapport.
Part (c). The danger is that two people might count different things. The fix is to decide, before starting, exactly what counts as a copy.
They should agree beforehand exactly what counts as a copy of posture, and what does not.
Why it scores: the working is shown, the two means are compared, and the result is linked to rapport. Remember that this is a small sample of 5 pairs each, so be careful about saying it shows how everyone behaves.
Longer answers: structure and levels
Longer questions, worth 4, 6 or 9 marks, are usually marked in levels: the whole answer is read, the level that fits best is chosen, then a mark inside it. These descriptions are Speca's own guide, the same as the one printed in the workbook; the real exam uses the exam board's mark schemes.
How to structure them
| 4 marks | Two points, each explained, or one point described and then explained in detail. If the question has a story in it, use the person's name in every point. |
| 6 marks | Three short paragraphs. To evaluate, use point, evidence, explain, link back in each one, and cover a strength and a weakness. To apply, name the idea, link it to the person in the story, then explain it. Finish with one sentence of judgement if the question asks you to evaluate. |
| 9 marks | Describe first: the theory or study, accurately, in a paragraph. If the question only says evaluate, keep this short. Then two or three evaluation points, each fully explained and using a study as evidence. Cover strengths and weaknesses. End with a judgement that answers the question. Do not spend all your time describing: the higher levels need evaluation as well. |
| Timing | The papers give 1 hour 45 minutes for 100 marks, so about a minute a mark: roughly 9 or 10 minutes for a 9-mark answer, including a minute to plan. |
The levels for a 4-mark answer
| Level | What it looks like |
|---|---|
| 3 to 4 marks | Clear, accurate and detailed. Each point is explained, and where there is a scenario the answer uses it. Psychological terms are used correctly. |
| 1 to 2 marks | Some relevant knowledge, but brief, muddled, or not applied to the question. |
| 0 marks | Nothing relevant. |
The levels for a 6-mark answer
| Level | What it looks like |
|---|---|
| 5 to 6 marks | Several relevant points, each explained clearly and accurately. If the question asks for evaluation, it says why each point matters. If there is a scenario, every point is applied to it. Well organised, with accurate terms. |
| 3 to 4 marks | Relevant points with some explanation, but some are thin, one-sided or only partly applied. |
| 1 to 2 marks | Points are listed or described but not explained, or the answer is mostly off the question. |
| 0 marks | Nothing relevant. |
The levels for a 9-mark answer
| Level | What it looks like |
|---|---|
| 7 to 9 marks | Accurate, detailed description and well-developed evaluation, using a study as evidence. Strengths and weaknesses are both covered, and the answer reaches a judgement. Clearly organised, with accurate terms. |
| 4 to 6 marks | Mostly accurate description with some evaluation, which may be one-sided or not fully explained. A study may be mentioned but not used as evidence. |
| 1 to 3 marks | Limited description, with little or no evaluation, or with errors. |
| 0 marks | Nothing relevant. |
One question, three answers
Discuss the relationship between language and thought. Refer to Piaget's view and the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis in your answer. [9 marks]
Read each answer, then the note on why it sits in that level. Try writing your own first, then compare.
Level 1: about 2 marks out of 9
Piaget said that language comes first and then thought follows. Sapir-Whorf said that thought comes first and language comes after. There is also a strong version of Sapir-Whorf and a weaker one. The Zuni have fewer words for colours than English so they have worse memory. Language is how we talk to each other and it matters a lot for thinking. Both ideas are important for psychology and both have good evidence so I think they are both right.
Why this level: The two views are the wrong way round: Piaget said thought comes first, and Sapir-Whorf said language comes first. The Zuni example is stated too strongly and too vaguely, because the research was about yellow and orange and about mixing up and remembering those colours. There is no real evaluation, only a general comment that both are right.
Level 2: about 5 marks out of 9
Piaget thought that thought comes first and language follows. A child must develop an idea through their cognitive development before they can use the words for it. For example, a child learns what bigger means by handling objects of different sizes. The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis says the opposite, that language comes first and shapes how we think. The strong version is linguistic determinism, which says language decides what we can think. The weak version is linguistic relativity, which says language influences how we think, for example what we notice and remember. There is some evidence for Sapir-Whorf. The Zuni language has one word for both yellow and orange. Early research found Zuni speakers were more likely to mix up those two colours and remembered them less well than English speakers, who have a separate word for each. This is a strength because it shows language can affect perception and recall.
A strength of Piaget's view is that children seem to understand some ideas before they have the words for them.
Why this level: Both views are described accurately, the strong and weak versions are separated, and the Zuni research is used as evidence. The evaluation only gives strengths, so it is one-sided. There are no weaknesses and no overall judgement about how language and thought are linked.
Level 3: about 8 marks out of 9
Piaget and the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis point in opposite directions. Piaget says thought comes first: a child must develop an idea through their cognitive development before they can understand and use the words for it, so language reflects what a child already thinks. The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis says language comes first and shapes how we think. Its strong version, linguistic determinism, says language decides what we are able to think, while the weak version, linguistic relativity, says language only influences how we think, for example what we notice and remember.
A strength of Piaget's view is that it fits evidence that children understand some ideas before they have the words for them.
However, it may underplay how language helps thinking to develop, and in real life the two are hard to pull apart, so Piaget's view may be too simple. For Sapir-Whorf, the Zuni language has one word that covers both yellow and orange. Early research found that Zuni speakers were more likely to mix up those two colours and remembered them less well than English speakers, who have a separate word for each. This is measurable evidence that language can affect perception and recall, so it supports the weak version.
However, the strong version is not supported, because people can notice differences they have no word for. If language decided what we could think, that would not be possible.
Overall, neither view explains the whole relationship, because each has a strength and a weakness, so each is partly right. The Zuni research suggests language influences thought, while Piaget's point that children understand ideas before they have words shows that thought can come first. I think the best conclusion is that language and thought affect each other, and that language influences thinking but does not control it.
Why this level: The description is accurate and detailed, with the direction of each view stated correctly and the Zuni research used as evidence. Strengths and weaknesses are covered for both views, and the answer sees that the evidence only supports the weak version. It reaches a clear judgement that follows from the evidence.
How to move up a level
- How to turn the Level 2 answer into Level 3: add a weakness for each view, for example that the strong version fails because people can notice differences they have no word for.
- Say which version of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis the Zuni research supports. It supports the weak version, linguistic relativity, not the strong one.
- End with a judgement that uses both sides, such as saying that language influences thought but does not control it, instead of just listing what each view says.
Sentence starters
Stuck on how to begin? Pick a starter and finish the sentence in your own words. The first set is for this topic; the second works for any topic.
For this topic
- Describe Linguistic relativity is the weaker version of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, which says that...
- Describe Piaget thought that thought comes first, so a child must...
- Explain Displacement is different from creativity because displacement means we can talk about..., whereas creativity means...
- Explain Postural echo is when one person copies another person's posture, and it signals rapport, so...
- Apply Ben and Tom sit on a bench and each leans forward with uncrossed arms. The way they match each other's posture is called..., and it suggests that...
- Evaluate One weakness of the strong version of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis is that people can notice differences they have no word for, which shows...
- Evaluate One strength of von Frisch's study is that he used careful, repeated observation of real bees, so...
- Judgement Overall, I think language influences thought but does not control it, because...
For any topic
- Describe One feature of ... is ...
- Describe In this study, the participants were asked to ...
- Describe The researchers found that ...
- Explain This happens because ..., which means that ...
- Apply In this situation, [name] is showing ..., because ...
- Apply This explains why [name] ..., because ...
- Evaluate One strength of ... is ... This is supported by ..., who found ...
- Evaluate However, one weakness of ... is ... This matters because ...
- Judgement Overall, ... is convincing because ...
- Judgement Overall, ... is limited because ...
- Judgement On balance, the evidence suggests ..., although ...
What this topic covers
- Describe Piaget's view that language depends on thought.
- Describe the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis and tell its strong and weak versions apart.
- Use the Zuni colour example to explain how language might affect memory.
- Give four functions of animal communication.
- Explain displacement and creativity as things human language can do.
- Describe and evaluate von Frisch's study of bees.
- Explain three functions of eye contact.
- Describe open posture, closed posture, postural echo, touch and personal space.
- Explain how culture, status and gender affect personal space.
- Describe Darwin's theory and the evidence that non-verbal communication is innate.
- Describe and evaluate Yuki's study of emoticons.
Where students lose marks
- Reversing the two theories. Piaget says thought comes first and language follows. The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis says language comes first and shapes thought.
- Mixing up the strong and weak versions. Linguistic determinism (strong) says language decides what we can think. Linguistic relativity (weak) says it influences how we think.
- Writing that animals cannot communicate. They can. Their signals are limited and tied to a job, and they are mostly about the here and now.
- Calling tone of voice verbal. It is non-verbal, because it is how something is said and not the words.
- Using Yuki's study as evidence for Darwin. Yuki found that how we read faces differs between cultures, which suggests it is learned.
Key terms
- Language
- A system of words and rules that lets us share ideas.
- Linguistic determinism
- The strong Sapir-Whorf view: the language we speak decides what we are able to think.
- Linguistic relativity
- The weaker Sapir-Whorf view: the language we speak influences how we think.
- Animal communication
- Signals animals use to pass on messages, usually about survival, mating, territory or food.
- Displacement
- Talking about things that are not here and now, such as plans for tomorrow.
- Creativity
- Joining a limited set of words to make an endless number of new messages.
- Round dance
- The bee dance that signals food close to the hive.
- Waggle dance
- The bee dance that signals food further from the hive, giving direction and distance.
- Verbal communication
- Passing on a message with words, spoken or written.
- Non-verbal communication
- Passing on a message without words, such as with the face, body, voice tone or distance.
- Open posture
- Uncrossed arms and legs, which signals being approachable.
- Closed posture
- Crossed arms or legs, which can signal being defensive or uncomfortable.
- Postural echo
- Copying another person's posture, which signals rapport.
- Personal space
- The area around us that we treat as our own.
- Evolutionary
- Explained by natural selection over very many generations.
- Innate
- Born with it, not learned.
- Neonate
- A newborn baby.
- Sensory deprivation
- Missing a sense from birth, for example being blind from birth.
- Emoticon
- A face made from keyboard symbols, such as a smiley.