Speca › Topics › GCSE Psychology

Social Influence

AQA GCSE Psychology · Paper 2

Social influence is about why people go along with a group, follow orders, stop to help or hold back, and act differently in a crowd. This page shows how to answer each kind of question, one step at a time.

Using the Speca Psychology Workbook?This is topic 5. Work through an example below, then go back to the questions in the book. The answers are at the back of the book.

Stuck? Worked examples, step by step

How to answer each kind of question in this topic. Cover the model answer, try it yourself, then check each step.

Also on this page: how longer answers are marked, with sample answers at each level · sentence starters

Define · 2 marks

Explain what a term means

Explain what is meant by the bystander effect. [2 marks]

Two marks usually means two parts: say what the term means, then add a reason or an example. Start with the main idea in your own words.

The bystander effect is when people are less likely to help someone in need when other people are present.

Now earn the second mark by saying why it happens. Use the key term 'diffusion of responsibility'.

This happens because responsibility is spread between everyone there, so each person feels less responsible.

Why it scores: the first sentence says what the effect is, and the second says why it happens. A fair examiner would credit both parts. A one-line answer such as 'people do not help' says less than the question asks for.

Explain · 3 marks

Explain how a factor affects behaviour

Explain how legitimate authority can affect obedience. [3 marks]

Three marks means three separate points. A good pattern is: what it means, what it does, an example. Start by saying what the term means.

Legitimate authority means the person giving the order is seen as having the right to give it, for example because of their uniform, their role or the setting.

Next, say what effect it has on obedience. Use the words 'higher' or 'lower' so the direction is clear.

Obedience is higher when the person giving the order is seen as legitimate.

Finish with a short, invented example. It shows you can use the idea, not only copy it.

For example, people are more likely to follow an order from a police officer in uniform than the same order from a stranger in everyday clothes.

Why it scores: it has a meaning, an effect with a clear direction, and an example. Each part is a different point, so each can earn its own mark.

Apply · 3 marks

Use an idea on a new situation

Harvey is in a science club. The leader holds up four unlabelled liquids and asks which one is the acid. Nobody in the club has done this before. The other three members all say 'B'. Harvey thinks it is 'D', but he says 'B'. Use your knowledge of task difficulty to explain why Harvey conformed. [3 marks]

Step 1, spot the idea. Look for clues in the story. 'Nobody has done this before' tells you the task is hard or unclear. 'All say B' is a majority. Harvey changing his answer to match is conformity.

Step 2, name the factor and say what it does. This is where you show you know the theory.

Task difficulty affects conformity: people conform more when the task is hard or unclear.

Step 3, link it to Harvey by using details from the story.

Harvey had never done this job before, so he was not sure of his own answer.

Step 4, explain the because. Say what Harvey did as a result.

Because he was unsure, he trusted the other three members and went along with their answer, so he conformed.

Why it scores: it names the factor, uses details from Harvey's story, and explains the cause in a chain. 'Peer pressure' on its own is too vague to name a factor, so always use the term the question asks for.

Study · 4 marks

Describe a named study

Outline Milgram's original 1963 study and explain how it supports Agency Theory. [4 marks]

A 4-mark 'describe' wants about four separate facts, not one long story. A plan that works for any study is: who took part, what they were asked to do, what was found. Start with who.

In Milgram's original 1963 study, 40 male participants took part.

Now say what they were told to do. Use the words 'what they believed' because the shocks were not real.

An experimenter told each participant to give what they believed were increasingly strong electric shocks to another person. The shocks were not real.

Now give the result. Only use the figure you are sure of.

65% of the 40 male participants went all the way to the maximum 450-volt switch.

Now link the result to the theory, because the question asks for it. Remember that people in the agentic state still act. They just feel the responsibility lies elsewhere.

Agency theory says they obeyed because they moved into an agentic state, seeing themselves as carrying out someone else's wishes.

Why it scores: it has the sample, the task, the key result and the link to the theory. A fair examiner would credit around four of these points. Do not add details you are not sure about, because a wrong detail does not help you.

Evaluate · 3 marks

Build one evaluation point

Explain one strength of Piliavin's subway study. [3 marks]

An evaluation point has four parts: Point (what the strength is), Evidence (a detail from the study), Explain (why that matters), Link (back to what it shows). Start with the Point.

One strength of Piliavin's study is that it was a field experiment in a real setting, so it has high ecological validity.

Evidence: pick a detail from the study that proves your point.

The study took place on a real New York subway train, with real passengers who did not know it was a study, and the 'victim' collapsed between stops.

Explain: say why that detail is good. Do not skip this step. It is the one that earns the mark.

This matters because people were behaving as they normally would, so the results are more likely to show how people really act when someone collapses than a task in a laboratory.

Link: finish by tying it back to the question.

So the study is good evidence about how real people decide whether to help.

Why it scores: it makes a point, backs it with a detail, and explains why the detail is a strength. Saying 'it was good because it was real' with nothing more would stay at the point only.

Plan a 6-mark answer

Plan, then write the hardest paragraph

Discuss the bystander effect as an explanation of why people sometimes do not help. Refer to Piliavin's study in your answer. [6 marks]

Step 1, decode the question. 'Discuss' means look at more than one side: what the idea says, and what could challenge it. Six marks means about three solid paragraphs, not six one-liners.

Step 2, plan three paragraphs before you write anything. Paragraph 1, the idea: define the bystander effect and explain diffusion of responsibility. Paragraph 2, another reason: the cost of helping (danger, effort, embarrassment). Paragraph 3, the challenge: use Piliavin's study to question the bystander effect.

Step 3, add a one-line conclusion. Say whether the bystander effect explains it fully, partly or not.

Step 4, write the paragraph that pupils find hardest first: paragraph 3. Start with a linking word such as 'however' so the examiner can see the challenge.

However, Piliavin's subway study does not clearly support the bystander effect. A victim collapsed on a real subway train, and help did not clearly fall as more bystanders were in the carriage.

Instead, the type of victim mattered. The victim with a cane was helped on about 95% of trials, but the victim who appeared drunk was helped on 50%.

This suggests that the cost of helping, such as mess, danger or embarrassment, may explain helping better than the number of people present. So the bystander effect may not be the whole story.

Why it scores: it uses the study as evidence, with figures, and it says what the evidence means for the question. Paragraphs 1 and 2 can be shorter. Pupils often write that Piliavin found a strong bystander effect, which is the opposite of the key finding.

Research methods · 6 marks

Percentages and a design choice

Cara tests 50 pupils on a simple job: which of two pieces of ribbon is longer? The difference is easy to see. Each pupil hears three confederates all give the same wrong answer first. In group X, 25 pupils answer out loud. In group Y, 25 pupils write their answer on a slip of paper. In group X, 15 pupils gave the same wrong answer as the confederates. In group Y, 5 pupils did. (a) Calculate the percentage of pupils who gave the wrong answer in each group. [2 marks] (b) Say what the results suggest about anonymity and conformity. [2 marks] (c) The confederates deceived the pupils. Suggest one way Cara could deal with this. [2 marks]

Part (a). Use part ÷ whole × 100. The 'whole' is the number in that group, which is 25. Write the sum out so you can earn marks even if you slip on the arithmetic.

Group X: 15 ÷ 25 × 100 = 60%.

Group Y: 5 ÷ 25 × 100 = 20%.

Part (b). Compare the two numbers first. Then say what it means in psychology words. Anonymity means nobody knows what you did.

The wrong answer was given 40 percentage points more often when pupils answered out loud (60%) than when they answered in writing (20%). This suggests that people conform less when their answers are private, because there is less pressure to match the group when nobody knows what you answered.

Part (c). A confederate is a person secretly working with the researcher, so the pupils were deceived. The usual fix is to tell them the truth afterwards.

Cara could debrief the pupils straight afterwards. She would tell them the real aim and that the other voices were confederates, and ask if they have any worries.

Why it scores: it shows the working, compares the figures, links the result to anonymity, and gives a practical way to deal with the ethical issue. This links to Asch's variation, where conformity fell when participants could write their answers privately.

Longer answers: structure and levels

Longer questions, worth 4, 6 or 9 marks, are usually marked in levels: the whole answer is read, the level that fits best is chosen, then a mark inside it. These descriptions are Speca's own guide, the same as the one printed in the workbook; the real exam uses the exam board's mark schemes.

How to structure them

4 marksTwo points, each explained, or one point described and then explained in detail. If the question has a story in it, use the person's name in every point.
6 marksThree short paragraphs. To evaluate, use point, evidence, explain, link back in each one, and cover a strength and a weakness. To apply, name the idea, link it to the person in the story, then explain it. Finish with one sentence of judgement if the question asks you to evaluate.
9 marksDescribe first: the theory or study, accurately, in a paragraph. If the question only says evaluate, keep this short. Then two or three evaluation points, each fully explained and using a study as evidence. Cover strengths and weaknesses. End with a judgement that answers the question. Do not spend all your time describing: the higher levels need evaluation as well.
TimingThe papers give 1 hour 45 minutes for 100 marks, so about a minute a mark: roughly 9 or 10 minutes for a 9-mark answer, including a minute to plan.

The levels for a 4-mark answer

LevelWhat it looks like
3 to 4 marksClear, accurate and detailed. Each point is explained, and where there is a scenario the answer uses it. Psychological terms are used correctly.
1 to 2 marksSome relevant knowledge, but brief, muddled, or not applied to the question.
0 marksNothing relevant.

The levels for a 6-mark answer

LevelWhat it looks like
5 to 6 marksSeveral relevant points, each explained clearly and accurately. If the question asks for evaluation, it says why each point matters. If there is a scenario, every point is applied to it. Well organised, with accurate terms.
3 to 4 marksRelevant points with some explanation, but some are thin, one-sided or only partly applied.
1 to 2 marksPoints are listed or described but not explained, or the answer is mostly off the question.
0 marksNothing relevant.

The levels for a 9-mark answer

LevelWhat it looks like
7 to 9 marksAccurate, detailed description and well-developed evaluation, using a study as evidence. Strengths and weaknesses are both covered, and the answer reaches a judgement. Clearly organised, with accurate terms.
4 to 6 marksMostly accurate description with some evaluation, which may be one-sided or not fully explained. A study may be mentioned but not used as evidence.
1 to 3 marksLimited description, with little or no evaluation, or with errors.
0 marksNothing relevant.

One question, three answers

Describe and evaluate the social factors that affect conformity. Refer to Asch's study in your answer. [9 marks]

Read each answer, then the note on why it sits in that level. Try writing your own first, then compare.

Level 1: about 2 marks out of 9

Conformity is when you follow an order from someone in charge. Social factors are things like group size and personality. Asch did a study with lines and people copied the group. The bigger the group the more people conform. Another social factor is task difficulty, because people copy more when the task is hard. It was a good study because it was in a lab so it was controlled.

Why this level: This confuses conformity with obedience: conformity is going along with a group, not following an order from someone in charge. It also puts personality in with the social factors, when personality is a dispositional factor. Only one social factor is named, the study is described in one line with no result, and the only evaluation is a single vague comment.

Level 2: about 5 marks out of 9

Conformity means changing what you do or say to match a group. Social factors come from the situation. One is group size, because conformity goes up as the majority gets bigger, up to a point. Another is anonymity. People conform less when their answers are private, because nobody can see them disagree. A third is task difficulty. People conform more when a task is hard or unclear, because they are less sure of their own answer. Asch's study tested this. Male American college students were put in a group with confederates and had to say which of three lines matched a target line. On the critical trials all the confederates gave the same wrong answer. Participants gave the wrong answer about a third of the time. In variations, conformity went up with group size and went down when answers were written privately.

One strength of Asch's study is that it was a controlled laboratory experiment, so the researchers could see which factors changed conformity. This means the findings about group size and anonymity are reliable.

Why this level: The description is mostly accurate and covers three social factors, and Asch's study is used with some detail. The evaluation is a single strength, so it is one-sided. There is no weakness, and no judgement about how far social factors explain conformity.

Level 3: about 8 marks out of 9

Conformity means changing what you do or say to match a group. Social factors come from the situation, and three affect conformity. Conformity rises as the majority gets bigger, up to a point. People conform less when their answers are private (anonymity), because nobody can see them disagree. People conform more when the task is hard or unclear (task difficulty), because they are less sure of their own answer. Asch's study gives evidence for all three. Male American college students were put in a group with confederates, who were secretly working with the researcher, and judged which of three lines matched a target line. On the critical trials all the confederates gave the same wrong answer, and participants gave the wrong majority answer about a third of the time. In the variations, conformity rose with group size up to about three confederates, fell sharply when answers were written privately and rose when the task was made harder.

A strength is that this was a controlled laboratory experiment with a standard procedure, so the variations show which social factors matter. This means we can be fairly confident that these social factors really do change conformity.

However, the line task was artificial and low stakes, so it may lack ecological validity, and the sample was only male American students in the 1950s, so it may not generalise. This matters because the findings may not apply to everyday conformity. Participants were also deceived. About a quarter of participants never conformed, so the situation does not explain everything. Dispositional factors help here, because people with low confidence may conform more, and people who know more about the task conform less.

Overall, social factors explain a lot of conformity, but they work together with the person, so the best explanation uses both.

Why this level: The description is accurate and detailed, with all three social factors explained and Asch's results used as evidence. Both strengths and weaknesses are developed, and the answer brings in dispositional factors to question how far the situation explains conformity. It ends with a clear judgement that is supported by what came before.

How to move up a level

Sentence starters

Stuck on how to begin? Pick a starter and finish the sentence in your own words. The first set is for this topic; the second works for any topic.

For this topic

For any topic

What this topic covers

Where students lose marks

Key terms

Conformity
Changing what you do or say to match a group.
Majority influence
The pressure to go along with what most people in a group are doing or saying.
Social factor
A reason for behaviour that comes from the situation, such as who else is there.
Dispositional factor
A reason for behaviour that comes from the person, such as personality or skills.
Anonymity
Nobody knowing who you are or what you did.
Obedience
Following a direct order from someone in authority.
Autonomous state
Acting on your own conscience and feeling responsible for what you do.
Agentic state
Seeing yourself as carrying out someone else's wishes, so the responsibility passes to them.
Legitimate authority
A person who is seen as having the right to give orders, for example because of their uniform, role or setting.
Proximity
How physically close people are, such as the person giving the order or the victim.
Authoritarian personality
A personality type with rigid thinking, strong respect for authority and hostility to people seen as lower status or different.
F-scale
The questionnaire Adorno used to measure the authoritarian personality.
Bystander effect
People are less likely to help when other people are present.
Diffusion of responsibility
Responsibility is spread between all the people present, so each feels less responsible.
Cost of helping
What it might cost you to help, such as danger, effort or embarrassment.
Prosocial behaviour
Behaviour that helps other people.
Antisocial behaviour
Behaviour that harms other people or breaks social rules.
Social loafing
Putting in less effort when working in a group, because your own contribution is less noticeable.
Deindividuation
Losing your sense of personal identity and responsibility in a crowd, which can lower inhibitions.
Confederate
A person who is secretly working with the researcher.

More GCSE Psychology topics