Speca › Topics › GCSE Psychology
Perception
AQA GCSE Psychology · Paper 1
Perception questions ask you to explain how we make sense of what we see, using two rival theories, illusions and two studies. This page shows how to build each kind of answer one step at a time, starting from what to write first.
Stuck? Worked examples, step by step
How to answer each kind of question in this topic. Cover the model answer, try it yourself, then check each step.
Also on this page: how longer answers are marked, with sample answers at each level · sentence starters
- Explaining a key word: inference
- Explaining one difference between the two theories
- Explaining an illusion with Gregory's theory
- Describing Gilchrist and Nesberg's study of hunger
- One weakness of Bruner and Minturn, built in four steps
- Planning a 'compare' answer on Gibson and Gregory
- Percentages and design in a perception experiment
Explain · 2 marks
Explaining a key word: inference
Explain what is meant by inference in Gregory's constructivist theory. [2 marks]
The question names Gregory's theory, so the two marks are: what the word means (1), and how it fits into Gregory's theory (1). If you only give a general meaning you get one mark at most. Start with the meaning in plain words.
Inference means working out the most likely explanation from incomplete evidence. (1)
Now bring Gregory in. Ask yourself two things: what is the 'incomplete evidence' for the brain, and where does it get the 'most likely explanation' from?
In Gregory's theory, what reaches the eyes is often incomplete or unclear, so the brain uses its past experience to make a best guess about what is there. (1)
If you have time, add that the guess is usually right, and that an illusion happens when the cues are misleading and the guess is wrong. It is not needed for the marks but shows you see the bigger picture.
Why it scores: the first sentence defines the word and the second applies it to Gregory's idea that perception is a best guess. Both marks are separate points.
Explain · 3 marks
Explaining one difference between the two theories
Explain one difference between Gibson's direct theory and Gregory's constructivist theory. [3 marks]
'One difference' means pick one clear difference and give both sides. For 3 marks: what Gibson says (1), what Gregory says (1), then a sentence that explains why that is a difference (1). The clearest choice is the role of past experience. Start with Gibson.
Gibson says perception is bottom-up. It starts with the information that arrives at the eyes, and the pattern of light (the optic array) is rich enough that no guessing or past experience is needed. (1)
Now Gregory, in the same shape so the contrast is obvious. Start with 'whereas'.
Whereas Gregory says perception is top-down. It starts with what the brain already knows, and the brain makes a best guess about unclear information using past experience. (1)
Now explain the difference, not just state it. Ask: what does each theory say about whether we have to learn to see? This is where nature and nurture come in. Careful here: Gibson is nature, Gregory is nurture. Pupils often swap them.
So Gibson says we do not need to learn to see, which makes his theory the nature side of the debate, whereas Gregory says what we see depends on past experience, which makes his the nurture side. (1)
Why it scores: both theories are described fairly, side by side, and the last sentence says why they differ. Two separate descriptions with no link between them often get only two marks.
Apply · 4 marks
Explaining an illusion with Gregory's theory
At a science museum, Nia watches her friends walk across a strange room. The room looks like an ordinary square room, but one friend looks huge when she stands in one corner and tiny when she stands in the other. Name this illusion and use Gregory's theory to explain why Nia sees it. [4 marks]
Step 1, spot the idea. A room that looks normal but is not, with a person who seems to change size: that is the Ames room. Name it clearly.
This is the Ames room illusion. (1)
Step 2, say what the theory claims about illusions. Gregory's idea is that perception is a best guess from past experience, and illusions happen when the cues are misleading.
Gregory's theory says perception is a best guess made using past experience, and an illusion happens when the cues are misleading, so the brain guesses wrongly. (1)
Step 3, link it to Nia. What do rooms usually look like? What is misleading here?
From past experience, rooms are usually square. This room looks like an ordinary square room but is really a different shape, so the depth cues are misleading. Nia's brain guesses that both corners are the same distance away, when really one is much further away than the other. (1)
Step 4, explain the result she sees. Bring in size constancy, the brain's assumption that things stay the same size, and use her friend.
Her brain assumes her friend stays the same size (size constancy), so when it gets the distance wrong it gets her size wrong too. She looks huge in one corner and tiny in the other. (1)
Why it scores: the illusion is named, Gregory's idea is stated, it is applied to the room and Nia, and it ends with what she sees. Several illusions can be explained in more than one way, so a fair examiner would credit any sensible, reasoned link.
Describe a study · 4 marks
Describing Gilchrist and Nesberg's study of hunger
Describe the aim, results and conclusion of Gilchrist and Nesberg's study of hunger and perception. [4 marks]
The question names the parts it wants, so write them in that order and use its words as signposts. Four marks means about four facts, so the results, which are the biggest part, get two of them. Aim first. A good starter is 'The aim was to find out whether...'.
The aim was to find out whether hunger, which is a need or motivation, changes how bright pictures of food look. (1)
Now the results. Two facts: what the hungry group did, and what happened the longer they went without food. Then say how the control group compared.
Students who had gone without food for 20 hours set the food pictures brighter than they really were. (1)
The effect grew the longer they went without food, whereas the control group, who ate normally, changed little. (1)
Last, the conclusion. Ask: what does this show about how our needs affect what we see?
The conclusion was that motivation affects perception: we are more sensitive to things linked to our needs. (1)
Why it scores: each part the question asked for is there, in order, and the results has two clear facts. You do not need to describe the whole method. If the question wanted the method it would say 'describe how'.
Evaluate · 3 marks
One weakness of Bruner and Minturn, built in four steps
Explain one weakness of Bruner and Minturn's study. [3 marks]
Build every evaluation point in four parts: Point (the weakness), Evidence (what in the study causes it), Explain (why it is a problem), Link back (what it means for the theory the study supports). Start with the point. Be specific about the kind of weakness.
One weakness is that the results may not generalise to everyday seeing.
Now the evidence. What did the researchers actually use? Think about the figure and how long people saw it.
The study used an artificial figure that could be read as the letter B or the number 13, and it was shown for a very short time. (1)
Now explain why this is a problem. Ask: is that how we normally look at things?
In everyday life we look at real objects for longer, with more information to use, so expectation might not have such a strong effect as it did on a brief, unclear figure. (1)
Finally, link back. The study was used to support Gregory's theory, which says expectation shapes what we see. So say what the weakness does to that support.
So the study gives weaker support for Gregory's theory, because we cannot be sure expectation shapes ordinary seeing in the same way. (1)
Why it scores: the weakness is named, backed with detail from the study, explained and linked to the theory. Avoid 'it was only a small study' unless you say why that matters here.
Plan a 6-mark answer
Planning a 'compare' answer on Gibson and Gregory
Compare Gibson's direct theory and Gregory's constructivist theory of perception. [6 marks]
'Compare' means say how they are alike and how they are different, not describe one and then the other. If you write 'Gibson says... Gregory says...' with no link, you get fewer marks. Plan three short paragraphs, and in each one put the two theories side by side with words such as 'whereas' and 'so'.
Your plan: Paragraph 1, where perception starts: bottom-up against top-down. Paragraph 2, the role of experience: nature against nurture. Paragraph 3, illusions: Gregory explains them as wrong guesses, Gibson finds them harder to explain; finish with a short judgement.
Now write paragraph 1. Open with one thing they share, then say how they split. Both theories are about how we make sense of the information that reaches the eyes, but they disagree about where perception starts.
Both theories are about how we make sense of the information that reaches the eyes, but they disagree about where perception starts. Gibson says perception is bottom-up: it starts with the pattern of light (the optic array), which holds enough information to tell us about depth, distance and movement directly, so no guessing is needed. Gregory says it is top-down: it starts with what the brain already knows, because the information is often incomplete, so the brain treats it as evidence and makes a best guess. (2)
Paragraph 2 follows the same pattern, so you write it yourself: Gibson says perception is innate, so it is the nature side, whereas Gregory says it depends on past experience, so it is the nurture side. Check you have not swapped them. Paragraph 3 uses a named illusion, such as the Müller-Lyer, and ends with a sentence such as 'Many psychologists think both processes matter.'
Why it scores: the paragraph contrasts the theories in the same sentences, which is what 'compare' asks for, and uses key words (bottom-up, top-down, optic array, best guess) correctly.
Research methods · 6 marks
Percentages and design in a perception experiment
Ms Dalton wants to test whether expectation changes what pupils see. She shows 50 pupils the same unclear drawing, which could be a dog or a sheep. She tells 25 pupils they are about to see farm animals. She tells the other 25 pupils they are about to see family pets. Afterwards, 15 of the farm group said 'sheep' and 6 of the pets group said 'sheep'. (a) Identify the independent variable and the dependent variable. [2 marks] (b) Calculate the percentage of each group who said 'sheep'. [2 marks] (c) Explain why Ms Dalton should use different pupils in each group. [2 marks]
Part (a). The independent variable is the thing the researcher changes or compares. The dependent variable is the thing measured. Ask: what did Ms Dalton change, and what did she count?
IV: what the pupils were told to expect (farm animals or family pets). (1) DV: whether each pupil said 'sheep'. (1)
Part (b). A percentage is: the number you want, divided by the total, times 100. Each group has 25 pupils, so 25 is the total. Do the farm group first.
Farm group: 15 ÷ 25 × 100 = 60% (1)
Now the pets group, with the same steps.
Pets group: 6 ÷ 25 × 100 = 24% (1)
You could also say how big the gap is. Take the smaller from the bigger. 60 - 24 = 36, so the farm group was 36 percentage points more likely to say 'sheep'.
The farm group was 36 percentage points more likely to say 'sheep', which fits the idea that expectation changes what we see.
Part (c). This is a design decision. Ms Dalton could use the same pupils twice, but then the second time they would already know the drawing can be two things. That is an order effect. Different pupils in each group (independent groups) avoids it.
If the same pupils saw the drawing twice, the first time would affect the second, because they would know it could be a dog or a sheep. (1) Using different pupils in each group means there are no order effects. (1)
Why it scores: the variables are named in terms of this study, both calculations are shown line by line, and the design choice is explained with a reason. Remember that using different pupils brings its own weakness, which is that the two groups may differ, so random allocation helps.
Longer answers: structure and levels
Longer questions, worth 4, 6 or 9 marks, are usually marked in levels: the whole answer is read, the level that fits best is chosen, then a mark inside it. These descriptions are Speca's own guide, the same as the one printed in the workbook; the real exam uses the exam board's mark schemes.
How to structure them
| 4 marks | Two points, each explained, or one point described and then explained in detail. If the question has a story in it, use the person's name in every point. |
| 6 marks | Three short paragraphs. To evaluate, use point, evidence, explain, link back in each one, and cover a strength and a weakness. To apply, name the idea, link it to the person in the story, then explain it. Finish with one sentence of judgement if the question asks you to evaluate. |
| 9 marks | Describe first: the theory or study, accurately, in a paragraph. If the question only says evaluate, keep this short. Then two or three evaluation points, each fully explained and using a study as evidence. Cover strengths and weaknesses. End with a judgement that answers the question. Do not spend all your time describing: the higher levels need evaluation as well. |
| Timing | The papers give 1 hour 45 minutes for 100 marks, so about a minute a mark: roughly 9 or 10 minutes for a 9-mark answer, including a minute to plan. |
The levels for a 4-mark answer
| Level | What it looks like |
|---|---|
| 3 to 4 marks | Clear, accurate and detailed. Each point is explained, and where there is a scenario the answer uses it. Psychological terms are used correctly. |
| 1 to 2 marks | Some relevant knowledge, but brief, muddled, or not applied to the question. |
| 0 marks | Nothing relevant. |
The levels for a 6-mark answer
| Level | What it looks like |
|---|---|
| 5 to 6 marks | Several relevant points, each explained clearly and accurately. If the question asks for evaluation, it says why each point matters. If there is a scenario, every point is applied to it. Well organised, with accurate terms. |
| 3 to 4 marks | Relevant points with some explanation, but some are thin, one-sided or only partly applied. |
| 1 to 2 marks | Points are listed or described but not explained, or the answer is mostly off the question. |
| 0 marks | Nothing relevant. |
The levels for a 9-mark answer
| Level | What it looks like |
|---|---|
| 7 to 9 marks | Accurate, detailed description and well-developed evaluation, using a study as evidence. Strengths and weaknesses are both covered, and the answer reaches a judgement. Clearly organised, with accurate terms. |
| 4 to 6 marks | Mostly accurate description with some evaluation, which may be one-sided or not fully explained. A study may be mentioned but not used as evidence. |
| 1 to 3 marks | Limited description, with little or no evaluation, or with errors. |
| 0 marks | Nothing relevant. |
One question, three answers
Describe and evaluate Gibson's direct theory of perception. Refer to Gilchrist and Nesberg's study in your answer. [9 marks]
Read each answer, then the note on why it sits in that level. Try writing your own first, then compare.
Level 1: about 2 marks out of 9
Gibson's theory says that we see things directly. It is bottom-up and it is nature. This means we are born able to see and do not need to learn. It uses the optic array which is the light that reaches the eyes. Gilchrist and Nesberg did a study on hunger and found hungry people saw pictures brighter. This supports Gibson's theory because it shows that perception is direct. Gibson's theory is a good theory.
Why this level: Some of the description is right (bottom-up, nature, the optic array), but it is brief and has no detail such as motion parallax. The answer also makes a mistake: Gilchrist and Nesberg's study supports Gregory's theory, not Gibson's, because a need changed what people saw. There is no real evaluation, only 'it is a good theory'.
Level 2: about 5 marks out of 9
Gibson's direct theory says perception is bottom-up, which means it starts with the information that arrives at the eyes. The pattern of light reaching the eyes is called the optic array, and Gibson says it is rich enough to tell us about depth, distance and movement directly. We do not need to guess or use past experience. One example is motion parallax: when we move, near objects seem to move past us faster than far ones, and this gives direct information about depth. Gibson says perception does not need to be learned, so it is innate and this is the nature side of the debate.
A weakness of the theory is that it finds illusions hard to explain. In an illusion the information is the same but it is seen wrongly. Gilchrist and Nesberg did a study where students who had gone without food for 20 hours set pictures of food brighter than they really were. This shows motivation affects perception. So Gibson's theory is not a very good theory.
Why this level: The description is accurate and detailed. The evaluation is one-sided, with weaknesses only, and Gilchrist and Nesberg's study is mentioned without explaining why its results are a problem for Gibson, so it is not really used as evidence. The ending is a short opinion, not a judgement.
Level 3: about 8 marks out of 9
Gibson's direct theory says perception is bottom-up: it starts with the information that arrives at the eyes. The pattern of light reaching the eyes, called the optic array, is rich enough to tell us about depth, distance and movement directly, so no guessing or past experience is needed. For example, in motion parallax, near objects seem to move past us faster than far ones when we move, which gives direct information about depth. Gibson says we do not need to learn to see, so perception is innate, which puts his theory on the nature side of the debate.
One strength is that the theory is built on information that is really there. Motion parallax shows that moving around can tell us about depth, so when the cues are clear we may not need to guess.
However, the theory has weaknesses. Illusions are hard for it to explain, because the same information reaches the eyes but is perceived wrongly. Gilchrist and Nesberg's study is also evidence against Gibson. Students who had gone without food for 20 hours set pictures of meals brighter than they really were, and the effect grew the longer they went without food, whereas the control group, who ate normally, changed little. This suggests a need, hunger, changed what people saw, which does not fit Gibson's claim that perception comes straight from the optic array, with nothing added by the person looking. The study has limits, because it used a small group of students and an artificial task, so we should not rely on it alone. But perceptual set, such as the effect of motivation or expectation, fits Gregory's theory better than Gibson's.
Overall, I think Gibson's theory explains how we use clear information like motion parallax, but it is incomplete. Illusions and the effect of hunger show that what the brain already has also shapes what we see, so it cannot be the whole explanation.
Why this level: The description is accurate and detailed. Gilchrist and Nesberg's study is used as real evidence: the answer gives the results and explains why they are a problem for Gibson, then notes a limit of the study. It covers a strength and weaknesses and ends with a judgement that gives reasons.
How to move up a level
- Use the study as evidence, not just a mention. Level 2 says the study 'shows motivation affects perception'. Level 3 gives the results (the effect grew the longer students went without food, and the control group changed little) and says why that is a problem for Gibson.
- Balance the answer with a strength. Level 2 only gives weaknesses. Level 3 says what Gibson's theory does well, using motion parallax, before the weaknesses.
- Add a limit of the study and a judgement. Level 3 says the study used a small group and an artificial task, then finishes by weighing the theory up and saying how far it explains perception.
Sentence starters
Stuck on how to begin? Pick a starter and finish the sentence in your own words. The first set is for this topic; the second works for any topic.
For this topic
- Describe Gibson says perception is bottom-up, which means it starts with...
- Describe In Gilchrist and Nesberg's study, students who had gone without food for 20 hours were asked to...
- Explain In the Müller-Lyer illusion the two lines look different because the brain treats the arrow-like ends as...
- Explain Gregory's theory is on the nurture side of the debate because it says what we see depends on...
- Apply Two players on a football pitch are the same height, but one makes a much smaller image in Zac's eyes. Zac's brain uses relative size to judge that this player is...
- Evaluate One weakness of Gilchrist and Nesberg's study is that it used a small group of students, which means...
- Evaluate One strength of Gregory's theory is that it explains illusions, because...
- Judgement Overall, I think Gregory's theory explains perception better than Gibson's because... However, Gibson's theory is still useful because...
For any topic
- Describe One feature of ... is ...
- Describe In this study, the participants were asked to ...
- Describe The researchers found that ...
- Explain This happens because ..., which means that ...
- Apply In this situation, [name] is showing ..., because ...
- Apply This explains why [name] ..., because ...
- Evaluate One strength of ... is ... This is supported by ..., who found ...
- Evaluate However, one weakness of ... is ... This matters because ...
- Judgement Overall, ... is convincing because ...
- Judgement Overall, ... is limited because ...
- Judgement On balance, the evidence suggests ..., although ...
What this topic covers
- Explain the difference between sensation and perception.
- Name and describe four monocular and two binocular depth cues.
- Describe Gibson's direct theory, including the optic array and motion parallax.
- Describe Gregory's constructivist theory and explain what inference means.
- Explain why Gibson's theory is the nature side and Gregory's is the nurture side.
- Give four reasons that illusions happen: ambiguity, misinterpreted depth cues, fiction and size constancy.
- Describe the Ponzo, Müller-Lyer, Rubin's vase, Ames room, Kanizsa triangle and Necker cube.
- Explain perceptual set and how culture, motivation, emotion and expectation affect it.
- Describe and evaluate Gilchrist and Nesberg's study of hunger.
- Describe and evaluate Bruner and Minturn's study of expectation.
- Use the illusions and the studies as evidence to judge the two theories.
Where students lose marks
- Treating sensation and perception as the same. Sensation is the senses detecting. Perception is the brain making sense of the signals.
- Calling convergence or retinal disparity monocular cues. They need two eyes, so they are binocular.
- Swapping the theories: Gibson is nature (bottom-up, innate) and Gregory is nurture (top-down, from experience).
- Writing a perceptual set as a fifth factor. It is the readiness to see things a certain way, and culture, motivation, emotion and expectation produce it.
- Giving one fixed reason for an illusion. Some illusions can be explained in more than one way, so give a reasoned link and name the idea you are using.
Key terms
- Sensation
- The sense organs detecting information from the world, such as light or sound, and sending signals to the brain.
- Perception
- The brain organising and interpreting those signals so they have meaning.
- Monocular depth cue
- A clue to distance that works with one eye.
- Binocular depth cue
- A clue to distance that needs both eyes.
- Height in plane
- Objects higher up in what we see, nearer the horizon, look further away.
- Relative size
- Of two objects we know are the same size, the one that makes the smaller image looks further away.
- Occlusion
- An object that partly covers another looks nearer.
- Linear perspective
- Parallel lines seem to come together as they go into the distance.
- Retinal disparity
- The two eyes get slightly different images; a bigger difference means the object is closer.
- Convergence
- The eyes turn inwards to look at close objects; the brain uses feedback from the eye muscles to judge distance.
- Optic array
- The pattern of light that reaches the eyes from the world, which Gibson says holds all the information we need.
- Motion parallax
- When we move, near objects seem to move past us faster than distant ones.
- Inference
- Working out the most likely explanation from incomplete evidence.
- Visual illusion
- Seeing something that is different from what is really there.
- Size constancy
- Assuming an object stays the same size as it moves away.
- Perceptual set
- A readiness to perceive things in a particular way.
- Bottom-up
- Perception that starts with the information from the senses.
- Top-down
- Perception that starts with what the brain already knows and expects.